Terence Richardson Group at Compass
Book a discovery call

Call or text (678) 785-5275

Reynoldstown, Atlanta GA

Updated September 2026 · Source: FMLS, compiled by the Terence Richardson Group

Reynoldstown is a Atlanta community in Fulton County. The FMLS archive we maintain shows 265 closed sales here since January 2020. That's enough to read this market on its own numbers, not Atlanta averages.

Over the trailing 12 months, Reynoldstown recorded 55 closed sales at a median price of $750,000. Median days on market: 33. That's about 5 weeks from list to contract, so buyers have room to compare and negotiate. The average close-to-list ratio was 98%, so the typical seller gave up about 2% between list and close. Since 2021, the annual median close price has moved from $725,000 to $830,000. That's up 14%. These figures come from the Terence Richardson Group's own FMLS closed-sales archive, refreshed monthly. It's the same data we price from.

As of September 2026, the pace here has been measured. That usually gives buyers room to negotiate. For sellers, week-one pricing discipline is the difference-maker.

Reynoldstown, by the numbers

$750,000
Median close price (trailing 12 mo)
55
Closings (trailing 12 mo)
33
Median days on market
$395
Median price per sq ft
98%
Avg close-to-list ratio

Data last updated: September 2026. Source: FMLS closed sales, compiled by the Terence Richardson Group. Sample: 55 closed sales.

How is the Reynoldstown market moving?

Median close price, Reynoldstown
TerenceRichardson.com $925K Oct 2023 Sep 2026 $1000K high

Source: FMLS closed sales, compiled by the Terence Richardson Group. Updated September 2026. Y-axis does not start at zero. Months with fewer than 5 closings are omitted from the line.

View the data table
PeriodValue
Oct 2023n/a
Nov 2023n/a
Dec 2023n/a
Jan 2024n/a
Feb 2024n/a
Mar 2024n/a
Apr 2024$1000K
May 2024$800K
Jun 2024$779K
Jul 2024$840K
Aug 2024$790K
Sep 2024n/a
Oct 2024n/a
Nov 2024$800K
Dec 2024$810K
Jan 2025n/a
Feb 2025n/a
Mar 2025$935K
Apr 2025$881K
May 2025$835K
Jun 2025$857K
Jul 2025$879K
Aug 2025n/a
Sep 2025n/a
Oct 2025$745K
Nov 2025n/a
Dec 2025n/a
Jan 2026n/a
Feb 2026n/a
Mar 2026n/a
Apr 2026$691K
May 2026$825K
Jun 2026n/a
Jul 2026$952K
Aug 2026$925K
Sep 2026n/a
Closed sales by month, Reynoldstown
TerenceRichardson.com 3 Oct 2023 Sep 2026

Source: FMLS closed sales, compiled by the Terence Richardson Group. Updated September 2026.

View the data table
PeriodValue
Oct 20231
Nov 20232
Dec 20234
Jan 20242
Feb 20240
Mar 20241
Apr 20245
May 20247
Jun 20246
Jul 20245
Aug 20246
Sep 20243
Oct 20242
Nov 20245
Dec 20245
Jan 20252
Feb 20252
Mar 20256
Apr 20255
May 20255
Jun 20257
Jul 20255
Aug 20253
Sep 20251
Oct 20255
Nov 20254
Dec 20250
Jan 20264
Feb 20263
Mar 20263
Apr 202612
May 20267
Jun 20262
Jul 20267
Aug 20265
Sep 20263
Median days on market, Reynoldstown
TerenceRichardson.com 39d Oct 2023 Sep 2026 108d high

Source: FMLS closed sales, compiled by the Terence Richardson Group. Updated September 2026. Months with fewer than 5 closings are omitted from the line.

View the data table
PeriodValue
Oct 2023n/a
Nov 2023n/a
Dec 2023n/a
Jan 2024n/a
Feb 2024n/a
Mar 2024n/a
Apr 202458d
May 20246d
Jun 20244d
Jul 20244d
Aug 202470d
Sep 2024n/a
Oct 2024n/a
Nov 20244d
Dec 202443d
Jan 2025n/a
Feb 2025n/a
Mar 202546d
Apr 202554d
May 202514d
Jun 202543d
Jul 202528d
Aug 2025n/a
Sep 2025n/a
Oct 2025108d
Nov 2025n/a
Dec 2025n/a
Jan 2026n/a
Feb 2026n/a
Mar 2026n/a
Apr 202620d
May 202626d
Jun 2026n/a
Jul 202618d
Aug 202639d
Sep 2026n/a

Subdivision samples are thin by nature; months with fewer than 5 closings are omitted from lines rather than plotted as misleading points.

TRG proprietary data

How often do listings fail to sell in Reynoldstown?

50% of Reynoldstown listings that left the market in the 12 months through September 2026 failed to sell: 55 withdrawn or expired against 55 closed.

That means nearly half of those listing attempts ended without a sale, after the prep, the showings, the waiting. Each relisting counts separately, so this measures attempts, not homes. Pricing and the first two weeks have a lot to do with which group a listing lands in, and it's the number listing agents almost never show you.

50%failed to sell

Geography: Reynoldstown, Metro Atlanta, GA · Period: 2025-10-01 to 2026-09-30

Source: FMLS withdrawn and expired records, compiled by the Terence Richardson Group. Sample: 110 terminated listings (55 failed, 55 closed). A failed listing left the market Withdrawn or Expired without closing. Rate = failed / (failed + closed) among listings terminating in the period. Relisted homes count per attempt.

Questions people ask

Reynoldstown questions, answered with data

What is the median home price in Reynoldstown?

The median home sale price in Reynoldstown is $750,000. That's based on 55 closed sales over the trailing 12 months. Source: FMLS data compiled by the Terence Richardson Group, updated September 2026.

How fast do homes sell in Reynoldstown?

Homes in Reynoldstown sell in a median of 33 days on market. That's about 5 weeks from list to contract, per trailing-12-month FMLS closed sales compiled by the Terence Richardson Group. Sellers have averaged 98% of list price at closing. Well-priced homes move faster than the median; overpriced homes are what carry it.

Is Reynoldstown a good place to buy a home in 2026?

Reynoldstown gives buyers room to work: the median home takes 33 days to sell, so offers get negotiated. Whether it fits you comes down to price band and timeline, and that's a data question. Terence Richardson of the Terence Richardson Group at Compass prices every recommendation from the group's own FMLS closed-sales dataset for Metro Atlanta, updated monthly.

Thinking about selling in Reynoldstown? Every valuation we prepare is hand-built from FMLS comps, including recent Reynoldstown closings around the $750,000 median. Request yours. Buying? Tell us what you're looking for.

Book a discovery call

The next step begins with a conversation with Terence.

You'll talk through where you are, what the market is doing where you want to be, and whether now is the time. If it isn't, he'll tell you.

Book a discovery callGet The Richardson Report
Terence Richardson at a wooden table with a coffee and a laptop