Terence Richardson Group at Compass
Book a discovery call

Call or text (678) 785-5275

VideosVideo and transcript

Even A $900K Price Cut Wasn’t Enough For This Atlanta Mansion

Plays here from YouTube when you press play. Open on YouTube

Published . Prices, rates and counts in this video were current on that date. This month's numbers are on Market Data.

What is this video about?

“Even A $900K Price Cut Wasn’t Enough For This Atlanta Mansion” is a 16-minute video by Terence Richardson, a Realtor with Compass in Metro Atlanta. It was published on October 30, 2026 on his YouTube channel, Terence Richardson - Atlanta Real Estate.

$129,000. That's what the typical Atlanta luxury seller gave up when their home sat on the market for more than two months. And it happens to about 1 in 3 luxury homes. For one seller in Tuxedo Park, the number was $2.5 million. I went through every $1 million plus sale in our 20 luxury areas over the last 12 months: the five biggest sales of September, who has the leverage at every price point, where the money is moving, and what both buyers and sellers should do about it right now.

Transcript

This comes from YouTube’s automatic captions, set into paragraphs. Nothing else was added or reworded. Captions can still mishear a word or a number, so check a figure against the video before you rely on it. Captions read November 16, 2026.

The $129,000 mistake 0:00

$129,000. That's what the typical Atlanta luxury seller gave up when their home sat on the market for more than 2 months. And that's not rare. About one in three luxury homes sat that long. Now, for one seller in Tuxedo Park, that number was 2 and 1/2 million. So, Atlanta's richest sellers just got a reality check. Meanwhile, the sellers who priced it right, the ones who sold in the first week got their asking price, even a little bit more.

So, I'm going to show you the five biggest sales this month, which luxury homes are selling, and which ones are just sitting, and the mistake behind that $129,000.

Who has the leverage at every price 0:41

Let's jump right into it. So, before we get into the sales, here's who has leverage at every price point, because in luxury, it depends a lot on the price. From 1 million to a million and a half, there's about 4 months of supply. That's a seller's market, and that's where almost six out of 10 luxury sales are happening right now. A million and a half to 2 million, 4.1 months, still a seller's market.

2 to 3 million, 5.6 months, that's balanced. And above 3 million, almost 12 months of supply. Call it a year's worth of homes for sale. That is a buyer's market, and it's not even close. So, if you're selling under 2 million, you still have leverage. Above 3 million, the buyer has it. But, averages only tell you so much. The sales tell the story. So, let's take a look at the five biggest ones from this past month.

September’s top 5 luxury sales 1:31

The top five. Number five is in the Atlanta Country Club in Marietta, about 13,000 square feet, built in 2003. It first asked 4.495. It sold for 4 and a quarter after 146 days. So, that's about 94 and a half percent of the first asking price, and that's right in line with the average for homes over 3 million. Remember that one, because number four is in the same neighborhood. Number four, also Atlanta Country Club, and here's what's crazy.

It closed the same day, September 10th. This first one asked six and a half million. It sold for 4.6 cash. That's about 71% of their first asking price, and it was on the market for 314 days. Same club, same day. One seller gave up about 245,000, while the other gave up 2 million. So, what's the difference? Same neighborhood, same timing. The difference was the first price. Now, here's what I think is going on in ACC.

It's had a big run. In 2021, a typical home there sold for under a million. Last year, about 1.8, and last fall, one sold for 7.9 million, the highest sale I can find in that neighborhood. But this year, it's slowed down quite a bit. The typical sale is taking about 74 days, up from 25 last year, and as many 2 million plus listings have been withdrawn or expired this year as in any year going all the way back to 2010.

Number four came out at about $550 a square foot. That's more per foot than the record sale. Number five came out right around what of this year's buyers are actually paying. Number three's in Morningside, about 8,700 square feet, built in 2013. First asked is under 5 million. It sold for 4.75 after 134 days. That's about 95% of their first asking price, and the seller still chipped in about $25,000 towards the buyer's closing costs.

Next, we go to Buckhead for number two, off of Paces Ferry. Almost 10,000 square feet. First asked is under 6 million, sold for five and a quarter after 111 days. So, about 88% of the first ask. Call it $745,000 given up. And number one, well, you've already met that one. That's the one that's in Tuxedo Park, 2 and a half million below the first ask. Now, I'm going to come back to that house because what happened in the middle of that deal is the whole lesson.

And congrats to the agents on every single one of these, by the way.

The sellers who won’t blink 4:07

The sellers who won't blink. Remember that 129,000? Here's where it comes from. Take a look at this. Every luxury home that sold in our 20 areas over the last 12 months, sorted by how long it sat on the market. The ones that sold in the first week, the typical one got its full asking price, actually a little bit more. 8 to 30 days, the typical seller gave up about 45,000. 31 to 60 days, 95,000.

And past 60 days, 129,000. So, the longer it sits, the more it costs every single step. Now, not every one of those homes was overpriced. Some are just harder to sell. Busy road, a strange floor plan, a lot that backs up to something, right? But when I look at the ones that sit, most of them were priced for the market the seller wished they had, not the market of the moment. And you see that the most clearly above 3 million.

Remember, that's a buyer's market, almost a year supply. So, you think everything up there is slow, right? Well, take a look at this. The typical 3 million plus home that sold went under contract in just 51 days. That time last year, it was 70. And 26% of them sold at or above their asking price. A year ago, it was 19%. So, the ones that are priced right are selling faster than they were a year ago.

As a matter of fact, the sixth biggest sale of the month proves it. The River Club in Suwanee, 4 and a quarter million. Suwanee is a buyer's market right now. And that house went under contract in just 8 days for cash at 97% of its first asking price. But here's the other side of it right now. 46% of the 3 million plus homes for sale have been sitting for at least 120 days.

It's almost half. And only 22% of them have cut their price. That's the lowest of any price range. So, you've got a pile of homes that aren't moving and the sellers who aren't blinking. So, what do you do with this? If you're a buyer above 3 million, your leverage on the homes that have sat for at least 120 days and still haven't cut, those sellers are probably tired. That's where you make the offer.

A fresh, well-priced listing up there is most likely going to get its price. If you're a seller, priced it for the first 30 days, the sellers who sold in the first week got their price. The ones who waited ended up paying for it, and the longer they waited, the more they paid.

The $2.5 million lesson in Tuxedo Park 6:41

And that's exactly what happened to the biggest sale of the month. Let me show you. So, let's go back to Tuxedo Park for a moment because this one's the whole lesson in one house. 10,000 sq ft built in 2020 on one of the quieter streets in Tuxedo Park. Absolutely gorgeous, right? It hit the market on May 15th at 12.75 million. And within 2 months, the seller cut the price down to 11.85.

Now, that's actually the right instinct. Cut early. Don't wait 6 months. But, it wasn't enough, and the house kept sitting. And finally, it went under contract in August, 101 days after it hit the market. And here's the part I want you to pay attention to. It closed in September for 10 and a quarter million cash. That happens to be $1.6 million below the price they already cut to. So, the first cut didn't catch the market.

The market was further away than the price, and the gap only got wider the longer that it sat. Now, how do you get to 12.75? Well, I went back and looked at what sold in Tuxedo Park before this house listed. The closest match is on Blackland Road. Same size, 10,000 sq ft, even newer. It sold in February for 8.3 million. That's about $830 a square foot, and it took almost 10 months to sell.

Now, this house came out at $1275 a square foot, more than 50% higher. Now, the big numbers in the neighborhood were bigger houses, 15 and 3/4 million on Tuxedo Road last year. That house went 20,000 sq ft. 10 million on Valley Road the year before, 12,000. Here's what I think really hurts. While the houses sat, a brand new house on the same street, 16,000 sq ft, sold for 13.8 million in 48 days.

That's about 850 a square foot. So, buyers at that level had a choice and a lot more house for the money down the street. And here's the twist, at 10 and a quarter, this buyer paid about a thousand and twenty-five dollars a square foot. That's the most per square foot I could find in Tuxedo Park for a house that size. So, the house was worth a premium, just not that one. So, if you're a seller, here's what I'd take from this.

When you cut cut all the way to where the market is, one real cut beats three small ones because every month you sit, buyers assume that there's something wrong with the house. And if you're a buyer, this is exactly the kind of house you watch. It sat, it cut, it sat again, and the buyer who showed up with cash got it for two and a half million under the asking price. But, how much you ask isn't the only thing that decides how fast you sell.

Where you are matters just as much.

Where the money moved 9:24

So, where the money moved? When you take a look at luxury sales by area, Buckhead is still king, about a billion dollars in luxury house sales over the last 12 months. Nobody else is even close. But, here's the thing, it's the only big luxury market that shrank. Buckhead's luxury sales volume is down 7% and the number of sales is also down 13%. Meanwhile, intown is up almost 21%. Sandy Springs up about 23%.

Roswell's up 25% and Vinings, which is a much smaller market, is up 72%. Quick note, when I say Buckhead, I mean the city of Atlanta side. Sandy Springs is its own number. Now, what I think is happening is this. Buckhead is still the standard, but those other areas have some fantastic options for luxury buyers depending on the lifestyle they want because each location offers something the others don't. And I saw this firsthand earlier this year.

I was helping a couple who wanted to buy in Sandy Springs or Buckhead up to about a million and a half. They grew up in Chastain Park and we looked at all of the options, every single one of them. In their price range, the good houses moved fast. The ones with condition issues didn't. In the end, they bought in Cobb and got a lot more for their money in terms of the house.

Came with a different lifestyle and that ended up working out for them. And here's a fun one. The single busiest luxury neighborhood in metro Atlanta? Morningside. 104 sales at a million dollars or more in the last 12 months. The typical one sold for about a million and a half at almost 98% of their first asking price. And over in Decatur, Oakhurst, the typical luxury sale got its full asking price, 100.2%. So, what do you do with that?

If you're buying in Buckhead, you've got more room to negotiate than you've had in a while. 5.4 months of supply and about four in 10 luxury listings have been sitting for more than 120 days. If you're selling in town or in Decatur, Dunwoody, or Brookhaven, you can price it right at the market and expect weeks, not months. Decatur has about two and a half months of supply, Dunwoody at 2.7. But, even in the same zip code, two luxury homes can be completely different markets.

And nowhere is that clearer than up the Georgia 400 corridor.

New vs. resale up Georgia 400 11:46

So, new versus resale. Across all 20 of our luxury areas, a resale home at a million dollars or more was about four months of supply. A brand new one, about 10 and a half months. So, new construction has well over twice the supply. And up the 400 corridor, it gets even wider. Take a look at Alpharetta. Resale, three and a half months. New construction, 15 months. It's the same story in Milton.

Resell 4.2, new 16.4. And in Alpharetta, 42% of luxury homes for sale right now are new construction. So, when people tell you that Alpharetta's luxury market is soft, it really depends on which half they're talking about. The resale side is still a seller's market. The new construction side, well, it has a lot of homes waiting for buyers. And you can see it in the price. The typical luxury home in Alpharetta sold for about $274 a square foot.

A year ago, it was 286. So, if you're a buyer and you want new construction up 400, you've got leverage with the builder right now. Ask for help with rates, upgrades, closing costs. Those homes are all competing with each other. If you're selling a resale home in Alpharetta or Milton, don't price off the new build sitting down the street. You're in a different market. Price it off the resale homes that actually sold in your competitive segment.

And if you're thinking about buying new and you plan to sell in a few years, keep this in mind. Your resale may end up competing with whatever the builder is offering at that time if that builder is not done, if they're still building. So, where does all of this leave each area?

City Watch: moving vs. sitting 13:25

So, City Watch, where luxury homes are moving and where they're sitting. The tightest luxury market in our 20 areas is Decatur, about 2 and 1/2 months of supply. Then, Dunwoody at 2.7, Vinings at 3, Brookhaven at 3.1. All of them seller markets. Now, on the other end, has about 7 and 1/2 months, Canton 7.2, and Suwanee 6.5. Those are the buyer markets. And in Canton, 62% of luxury listings over the last 12 months ended without a sale.

That counts the ones that were taken off and put back on, but still, that's still a lot of sellers who didn't get where they wanted to go.

Woodstock’s one-year flip 14:05

Now, here's the one that surprised me, Woodstock. Because this time last year, Woodstock had about 9 months of supply, right? Luxury supply. That's a buyer's market. Today, 4.3. That's a seller market in what year? So, what happened? Well, I dug into it. More luxury homes actually came on the market in Woodstock this year than last year, but about twice as many were withdrawn or expired without selling. So, a lot of that supply just vanished.

It left. At the same time, luxury sales in Woodstock went up about 18%. Fewer homes sitting and more homes selling. That's how you get a seller's market. And I think there's a real reason buyers keep showing up, right? They keep building in downtown Woodstock. Every time you drive by, there's something new. Nearby Holly Springs is the same, and it's become a real hot spot. So, if you're selling in Woodstock right now, you've got less competition you've had in a while, but a lot of the sellers who pulled out are still there.

If they came back in the spring, that could change. So, if you're in one of the blue areas, price to the market, and it moves. In the dark areas in the map, the buyers have time, and they know it.

Bringing it all back 15:08

So, let's bring it all back. Who got the reality check? The sellers who priced for the market they wanted instead of the ones they're in. The typical luxury home that sat for more than two months gave up $129,000 in Tuxedo Park. It was 2.5 million. And who has the leverage? Under 2 million, sellers still do. Above 3 million, buyers do. So, if you're buying, make your offers on the 3 million plus homes that have sat for 120 days and haven't cut.

If you want new construction up Georgia 400, ask the builders for help. And in Buckhead, you've got time. In Decatur and Dunwoody, you don't. If you're selling, price it for the first 30 days because the first week sellers got their price. When you cut, cut all the way to where the market is. And in Alpharetta or Milton, price off the resale homes that actually sold, not the new construction ones. Now, number six through 10 on the top sales list in every city table I didn't have time for are in the luxury issue of my newsletter, The Richardson Report.

Absolutely free to sign up. If you're interested in it, check the link in the description and in that first comment. This video focuses on the million dollar plus segment of the market. If you're interested in finding out what's happening under a million dollars in Metro Atlanta, I deep dive it in this video here. Feel free to watch that one next.

Terence Richardson

About Terence Richardson

Terence Richardson is a Realtor with Compass and the founder of the Terence Richardson Group, which serves Metro Atlanta. He publishes Atlanta’s Housing Market Update every month on YouTube and in The Richardson Report.

Let's apply this to your next move.

Buying, selling or relocating to Atlanta, you're welcome here. Tell Terence where you are, and he'll go through the numbers and the tradeoffs for your street, your price range and your timing.

Terence Richardson at a wooden table with a coffee and a laptop